All-on-4 vs. Dentures: Which Is Right for You? If you wear dentures today, you likely chose them because they were the right answer at the time. For many patients, a well-made denture restored their smile and their ability to eat when other options were out of reach. Over the years, though, a lot of denture wearers find themselves working around their teeth: avoiding certain foods, keeping adhesive on hand, and noticing that a denture which once fit well now shifts when they talk or laugh. All-on-4 dental implants offer a different path. Instead of a removable plate that rests on the gums, an All-on-4 restoration is a full arch of fixed teeth anchored to four dental implants placed in the jawbone. At South Valley Oral and Facial Surgery, Dr. Joseph McMurray and Dr. Arian Chehrehsa see many patients who come to us after years of wearing dentures, and for most of them the question is not whether dentures served them well, but whether there is something better suited to where they are now. This page walks through how the two options compare in daily life, in long-term cost, and in what the transition actually involves, so you can decide which is the right fit for you. Call our San Jose office at 408-479-9449 to schedule your consultation. What Is the Difference Between All-on-4 and Dentures?A conventional full denture is a removable prosthesis. It sits on top of the gums and is held in place by suction, the shape of the ridge beneath it, and in many cases a denture adhesive. Because the gums and underlying bone change over time, dentures need to be relined and eventually remade, typically every five to ten years depending on the patient. An All-on-4 restoration is a fixed prosthesis. Four dental implants are placed in the jawbone, with the two back implants angled to make the most of available bone and, in many cases, avoid the need for bone grafting. A full arch of teeth is then secured to those implants. You do not take it out at night, it does not need adhesive, and only your dental team removes it for professional cleaning and maintenance. Patients who want something in between sometimes consider an implant-retained overdenture, such as a bar attachment denture, which snaps onto implants for stability but still comes out for cleaning. How Do They Compare Day to Day?EatingMany denture wearers gradually narrow their diet without realizing it. Steak, raw vegetables, corn on the cob and crusty bread become difficult, and an upper denture that covers the roof of the mouth can mute the taste and temperature of food. Because All-on-4 teeth are anchored to implants, patients regain much stronger chewing function, and the upper prosthesis leaves the palate open. Speaking and confidenceA denture that slips during a conversation or a meal with friends is one of the most common reasons patients come to see us. All-on-4 teeth are fixed, so there is no movement to manage. Patients often tell us the biggest change is not functional at all: it is no longer thinking about their teeth. Bone preservationWhen natural teeth are lost, the jawbone that once supported them begins to shrink. A denture resting on the ridge does nothing to slow this, and over years it is a major reason dentures loosen and facial contours change. Dental implants transmit chewing forces into the bone much as tooth roots do, which helps maintain bone volume around the implants. How Does the Cost Compare Over Time?Dentures cost less upfront, and that is a real consideration. Over the long term, though, the comparison changes. Dentures are typically relined periodically and remade every several years as the jaw changes, and many wearers add the ongoing cost of adhesives, soft liners and repairs. Over two or three decades, those costs add up. All-on-4 is a larger investment at the start. The implants are intended to be a permanent foundation, and the fixed teeth need routine professional cleanings and occasional maintenance rather than repeated replacement. For many patients, especially those who expect to live with their restoration for twenty years or more, the lifetime cost difference is smaller than the initial price suggests. Your actual cost depends on whether you need one arch or both, the condition of your bone, and the type of final prosthesis. Switching From Dentures to All-on-4Many of our All-on-4 patients are long-time denture wearers who simply reached the point where the limitations outweighed the convenience. The transition is more straightforward than most expect. After a consultation and 3D imaging to evaluate your bone, the procedure can typically be completed in a single surgical visit: any remaining failing teeth are removed, the four implants are placed, and a fixed provisional set of teeth is attached the same day. You do not leave our office without teeth. The provisional teeth are designed for a softer diet while the implants fuse with the bone over the following months. Once healing is complete, your final prosthesis is made and secured in place. Because Dr. Chehrehsa is dual board-certified in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Anesthesiology, and both surgeons have extensive experience in full-arch implant surgery, patients have access to IV sedation or general anesthesia for the procedure. For many former denture wearers who have avoided dental care out of anxiety, this makes the decision much easier. Is Every Denture Wearer a Candidate for All-on-4?Not always, and it is important to be honest about that. Patients who have worn dentures for many years often have significant bone loss, particularly in the upper jaw. All-on-4 is designed to work with reduced bone, but some patients do not have enough bone in the right places to support conventional implants, even angled ones. That does not mean fixed teeth are off the table. Both Dr. McMurray and Dr. Chehrehsa specialize in zygomatic implants, which anchor in the dense cheekbone rather than the upper jaw and can support a full arch of fixed teeth for patients who have been told they have too little bone for implants. Other patients may benefit from bone grafting or sinus lift surgery before implant placement. Which Is Right for You?Dentures remain a reasonable choice for some patients, particularly those who are comfortable with them or who are not ready for surgery. If you find yourself planning meals around your teeth, relying on adhesive to get through the day, or noticing that your dentures fit less securely each year, All-on-4 is worth a closer look. Dr. McMurray and Dr. Chehrehsa see patients for All-on-4 consultations at our offices in San Jose, Gilroy and Los Banos. At your visit, we will review your dental history, take 3D imaging, and talk through every option that fits your anatomy and goals, from All-on-4 to zygomatic implants to implant-retained dentures. |
Related Dental Implant Services
|
PhoneSan Jose: (408) 479-9449 Gilroy: (408) 479-8788 Los Banos: (209) 270-5361 HoursMon - Fri: 7:30am - 5:00pm Saturday: Closed Sunday: Closed |